
As families prepare for another school year, many focus on tuition costs, course registration, and housing arrangements. One planning opportunity that often gets overlooked is how and when to withdraw funds from a Registered Education Savings Plan (RESP).
While RESPs are well-known for helping families save for post-secondary education, withdrawal decisions can affect both taxation and the overall value derived from the plan. As a student approaches graduation, thoughtful planning can help ensure you fully benefit from the tax advantages, investment growth, and government grants accumulated over the years.
Understanding RESP withdrawals
When a beneficiary (student) is actively enrolled in a qualifying post-secondary program, proof of enrolment will be required to make a RESP withdrawal. Eligible withdrawals can generally be taken in two ways:
|
Funds come from |
Tax treatment |
Limits |
|
|
Education Assistance Payment (EAP) |
Government grants + investment growth earned with RESP |
Taxable to student in the year withdrawn but may result in little or no tax due to student’s lower tax bracket |
During the first 13 weeks of enrolment withdrawals are limited to $8,000 for full-time and $4,000 for part-time students. Subject to annual maximum of $29,459. |
|
Post-Secondary Education (PSE) Withdrawal |
Original contributions |
Withdrawn tax-free |
No prescribed limit |
Leaving the door open for future education
One of the strengths of an RESP is its flexibility. Plans can remain open for up to 35 years, allowing families to preserve funds for future educational opportunities such as graduate degrees or other qualifying post-secondary programs.
In a family RESP, government grants can be shared among beneficiaries, subject to the maximum grant limit currently available to each individual ($7,200). This flexibility can be helpful if one child does not pursue post-secondary education or does not fully utilize their available grants.
Maintaining a balance within the plan may be worthwhile if there is a reasonable possibility that one or more beneficiaries will pursue additional education. Any remaining funds continue to grow on a tax-deferred basis and can later be withdrawn as EAPs, with the taxable income attributed to the student.
This flexibility is particularly valuable in today’s environment, where career paths often evolve, and returning to school later in life has become increasingly common. Keeping an RESP open preserves this optionality without immediate tax consequences.
If RESP funds remain unused
Ironically, one of the biggest RESP mistakes is being too cautious with withdrawals. We often see families withdraw only small amounts each year, only to discover near graduation that a significant balance remains in the plan. Because government grants and investment growth are taxed in the student’s hands, the ideal time to withdraw these funds is typically while they are enrolled in school and have little other income. Taking larger withdrawals during the second, third, and fourth years of a program can often result in little or no tax for the student and help avoid a much larger tax bill later for the subscriber.
If no beneficiary pursues further education, the RESP will eventually be wound down (provided the beneficiary is at least 21 years old), and the tax treatment becomes less favourable.
When an RESP is collapsed, the assets are essentially split into three categories:
- Government grants – any unused grants remaining must be repaid to the government
- Original contributions – returned to the subscriber (who owns the RESP) tax-free
- Accumulated investment growth – withdrawn as an Accumulated Income Payment (AIP)
AIP withdrawals are subject to full taxation in the subscriber’s hands as interest income, regardless of how the income was earned within the plan. In addition, a 20% surtax applies on top of regular income tax, making it the most punitive and least favourable tax outcomes available within an RESP.
Case study
This case study highlights the importance of withdrawal planning. In this example, an RESP still holds $100,000 after a child completes their education, including $36,000 of original contributions, $7,200 of grants and $56,800 of accumulated investment income.
Had the growth and grant portion been withdrawn as EAPs during the student’s studies, the tax liability may have been minimal or nil.
If funds remain in the RESP after studies are complete, an RRSP transfer of eligible accumulated income may help mitigate tax, subject to available RRSP room and a $50,000 AIP transfer limit. Unlike a regular RRSP contribution, the transfer does not create an additional tax deduction. Rather, the deduction is generally used to offset the taxable AIP, allowing the funds to remain tax-deferred within the RRSP. If a rollover is not possible, the tax consequences can be substantial. Assuming the subscriber is in a 30% average tax bracket, the tax cost on the $56,800 of remaining growth would be $28,400.
|
An RESP Holding $100,000 |
Scenarios |
RRSP Transfer |
Applicable tax rules |
Total Tax & Penalty amount (20% penalty + assuming 30% marginal tax rate) |
|
Contributions = $36,000 Grants (max lifetime) = $7,200 |
#1: Withdrawn by student during studies |
N/A |
$36,000 – withdrawn tax-free |
Often minimal or nil |
|
#2: $50,000 RRSP transfer |
$50,000 |
$36,000 – returned to subscriber tax-free; |
$6,800 x 30% tax rate & x 20% penalty = $3,400 |
|
|
#3: No RRSP room available |
$0 |
$36,000 – returned to subscriber tax-free; |
$56,800 x 30% tax rate & x 20% penalty = $28,400 |
Key takeaways for families
As students return to campus, this is an ideal time to revisit your RESP strategy. If the eligible RESP beneficiary is nearing completion of their program, decisions made today can directly influence the tax efficiency of withdrawals and the overall value derived from the RESP.
- If additional schooling is expected or possible, maintaining some balance in the RESP may be appropriate
- If further education is unlikely, prioritizing RESP withdrawals while the beneficiary remains eligible can help maximize the value of the plan and avoid less favourable tax outcomes on unused funds
Thoughtful planning can help families maximize the value of RESP benefits, including tax-deferred growth, government grants, and opportunities for tax-efficient withdrawals. As always, reviewing withdrawal strategies alongside your broader financial plan can help ensure decisions remain aligned with both short-term needs and long-term objectives.
For additional information, please refer to the Government of Canada’s resources on RESP withdrawals and AIPs:
- Registered Education Savings Plans payments, transferring and rolling over Registered Education Savings Plans property
- RESP – Accumulated Income Payments
- Managing the Registered Education Savings Plan, taxes and transfers
- Registered education savings plan (RESP) Bulletin No.1R3
National Bank Financial – Wealth Management (NBFWM) is a division of National Bank Financial Inc. (NBF), as well as a trademark owned by National Bank of Canada (NBC) that is used under license by NBF. NBF is a member of the Canadian Investment Regulatory Organization (CIRO) and the Canadian Investor Protection Fund (CIPF), and is a wholly-owned subsidiary of NBC, a public company listed on the Toronto Stock Exchange (TSX: NA).
The opinions expressed do not necessarily reflect those of NBF. The particulars contained herein were obtained from sources we believe to be reliable, but are not guaranteed by us and may be incomplete. The opinions expressed consider a number of factors including our analysis and interpretation of these particulars, such as historical data, and are not to be construed as a solicitation or offer to buy or sell the securities.